Wednesday 15 March 2017

Alexander Blackman Finally Cleared Of Murder But Convicted Manslaughter

Alexander Blackman

A historic murder conviction against a British marine who shot dead a seriously wounded Taliban prisoner in Afghanistan has been quashed and replaced with one of manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility.

Alexander Blackman became the first member of the UK armed forces in recent history to be convicted of murder while on an overseas tour and has been serving a life sentence in a civilian prison since 2013.

Blackman, who was not at the Royal Courts of Justice to hear the decision, remains in prison for the moment but will be re-sentenced within the next couple of weeks and at that point could be released.

Outside court Blackman’s wife, Claire, who has led the campaign to free the former sergeant, said she was delighted by the result saying it “much better reflected the circumstances that my husband found himself in during that terrible tour of Afghanistan”.

Emerging on to the steps of the Royal Courts of Justice to applause from a crowd of veterans – including three cheers for her – and the honking of taxi horns, she said: “We must now hope to secure a significant reduction in the sentence.”

Alexander Blackman

She thanked her husband’s “fantastic” legal team and the “tens of thousands of supporters, especially from the Royal Marine family, who have stood behind us throughout and played such an important role in getting us to this point”.

The appeal was heard by some of the country’s most senior judges including Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd, the lord chief justice, and Sir Brian Leveson, president of the Queen’s bench division.

In Wednesday’s ruling, the appeal court judges said Blackman had been “an exemplary soldier before his deployment to Afghanistan in March 2011”.

They ruled: “The appellant suffered from quite exceptional stressors ... during the time of that deployment which increasingly impacted on him the longer he was in command at CP [command post] Omar.”

The judges said it was “clear that a consequence was that he had developed a hatred for the Taliban and a desire for revenge”. At the time of the killing “the patrol remained under threat from other insurgents”.

The judges said: “Given his prior exemplary conduct, we have concluded that it was the combination of the stressors, the other matters to which we have referred and his adjustment disorder that substantially impaired his ability to form a rational judgment.”

A trial at the military court centre in Bulford, Wiltshire, was told that a patrol led by Blackman was tasked with assessing a Taliban fighter badly injured by Apache helicopter cannon fire.

The insurgent’s assault rifle lay within his reach and there was a grenade in his pocket, but the marines disarmed him professionally.

The court heard how the prisoner was then dragged roughly to the edge of the field. He was sworn at and mocked before being dumped on a pile of chaff.

Once the Apache had gone and the marines had made sure they were out of sight of a British observation balloon, Blackman leaned in and shot the helpless man in the chest.

As the insurgent’s body twitched, Blackman told him: “There you are, shuffle off this mortal coil, you cunt. It’s nothing you wouldn’t do to us.” Moments later, he told colleagues: “Obviously this doesn’t go anywhere fellas. I’ve just broken the Geneva convention.”

While the patrol kept quiet, the incident in September 2011 had been captured on a head camera worn by one of the men, referred to as Marine B. A year later the video was found by chance by military investigators and an inquiry began.

The trial judge, Jeff Blackett, said the prisoner had been “executed” and told Blackman: “In one moment you undermined much of the good work done day in and day out by British forces and potentially increased the risk of revenge attacks against your fellow service personnel.”

Blackman was jailed for life and told he would spend at least 10 years in prison, a tariff later reduced to eight. He was also dismissed with disgrace.

After that ruling, the Daily Mail launched a “campaign for justice” for Blackman, portraying him as a brave, loyal marine who had been working in the most challenging conditions with little supervision or backup from his superiors. Mail readers donated £800,000 to a legal fund administered by the author Frederick Forsyth, Maj Gen John Holmes, the former head of UK special forces, and the composer Sir Tim Rice.

A new legal team put fresh evidence and arguments before the Criminal Cases Review Commission, which referred the case back to the court martial appeal court, on the grounds that new details relating to Blackman’s mental state at the time were available and because an alternative verdict of manslaughter had not been presented to the court martial board when it originally considered the case.

The judges said that if the expert evidence of the psychiatrists, and other evidence, had been before the court martial, “we are in no doubt but that the defence of diminished responsibility would have had to have been left to the board and that it could have affected their decision to convict”.

They said: “It matters not for this purpose that the evidence as to conditions in Afghanistan is disputed by the prosecution. That evidence plainly had sufficient force and credibility (even if disputed) together with the psychiatric evidence to form the basis of a case that the defence of diminished responsibility … could be advanced.

“Such a case, if it had been advanced before the board could have raised a doubt as to guilt in the minds of the board. As a result, the verdict is unsafe and the conviction for murder must be quashed.”

The judges said they wished to “make it clear” that the court could see “no basis for any criticism of the conduct of the court martial by the judge advocate general”, who “left the issues which had been raised by the prosecution and the defence during the hearing of the court martial to the board in an entirely fair and proper manner”.

During the appeal, Blackman’s team, led by Jonathan Goldberg QC, said the marine had adjustment disorder, a mental illness. At the time of the offence, they argued, he had reached the point where he did not – or could not – care. He was burnt out and his moral compass was affected.

Neil Greenberg, a psychiatrist, told the court that everybody had their “breaking point”. “There is no such thing as a Rambo type, an Arnold Schwarzenegger soldier, who can face all sorts of stresses and appear to be invulnerable,” he said. “That sort of person only exists in the cinema.”

Blackman and his colleagues were in Helmand as part of Operation Herrick 14, which ran from March to October 2011, to help build schools, hospitals and roads and train Afghan forces. But they also had to cope with a determined and motivated enemy and they lost close friends. One man lost a leg in a roadside bomb. It was hung by the Taliban from a tree as a trophy. The troops said they feared that if they were captured they would be skinned alive or beheaded.

Blackman was in charge of command post Omar, a tiny roofless compound with no lock on the back gate. His commanding officer visited twice at most during the six months he was there.

By September, partly because of the number of injuries, the men under Blackman’s command had only one day of rest every two or three weeks. Blackman began to go out on almost every patrol. He was feeling stressed, jaded and paranoid, believing the Taliban were specifically targeting him. Under that pressure, he snapped.

An MoD spokesperson said: “We have fully cooperated with each stage of Sgt Blackman’s case, which has now involved a criminal investigation, a court martial and the appeal process, and will continue to provide personal support to the family, as we have done since charges were first brought. We respect the court’s decision and it would be inappropriate for us to comment further on it.”



Etiam at libero iaculis, mollis justo non, blandit augue. Vestibulum sit amet sodales est, a lacinia ex. Suspendisse vel enim sagittis, volutpat sem eget, condimentum sem.